Reading the Pack
How to size up the pack before every discard: who could take it next, what a pick would give them, and when one pick is likely to decide the hand.
In this lesson
- Check whether the next player can take the pack with your discard
- Apply the pair rule, the five-card block and dead ranks to any top card
- Work out what a pick gives the picker
- Weigh when a pack is big enough to decide the hand
Practise with Canasta Meld Trainer: Is My Opening Legal?.
Lesson 4 taught the rule for picking the pack. This lesson is about reading it. Before every discard, a club player looks at the pack and asks three things: who could take it next, what a pick would give them, and how much is riding on it. The first question has a right answer every time. The others are judgement, and the lesson says which is which.
Who can take the pack next
Only the player whose turn it is can take the pack, and only by using its top card. So the card you discard sits on top for exactly one player: the next player, on your left, who is always an opponent. If that player draws from the stock instead, their own discard covers yours.
That leaves one question to ask before every discard: can the next player take the pack with this card? Four things answer "no":
- The rank is dead. Once either team finishes a canasta of a rank, neither team may start or add to that rank (the CLA and Pagat.com agree). The top card cannot be melded, so the pack cannot be taken.
- Their team has five or six of the rank on the table. A pick puts three more cards on that meld, and no meld may pass seven. The CLA says it directly: no pick on a meld of five or more.
- The next player cannot hold two of the rank. Pagat.com requires a natural pair from the hand for every pick. If your count from Lesson 13 leaves at most one copy unseen, they do not have two.
- The card is wild. Pagat.com says no one may take a pack topped by a two or a joker, because no natural pair matches it. You will almost never throw one, since a wild discard is allowed only in the rare cases Lesson 13 described.
Check 3 needs one warning. The CLA's rules page also describes picking by adding the top card to a meld already on the table, without a pair, and Lesson 4 explains the two readings. At a table that plays it that way, check 3 works only for ranks the next team has not melded.
Anything that passes all four checks is a "maybe": the next player can take it if they hold the pair.
Worked example. The next player's team has J, J, J, J, J (five jacks), 9, 9, 9, 9 (four nines) and a finished natural canasta of kings. You are choosing among a jack, a nine, a king and a six.
- Jack: no. Five jacks plus three more cards would be eight.
- King: no. Kings are dead.
- Nine: yes, if they hold two nines. Four plus three is exactly seven, so the pick would also finish a natural canasta of nines. This is the most dangerous card you hold.
- Six: maybe. Nothing you can see rules out a pair of sixes.
Question 1 of 4
With the table from the worked example, which discard could let the next player take the pack and finish a canasta in the same move?