Safe Discards I: Provably Safe
The three ways to prove the next player cannot take your discard, the house rules that weaken them, and how the empty tray turns your safest cards into illegal ones.
In this lesson
- Prove a discard safe by a dead rank, a meld of five or six, or a count
- Know which proofs hold at every table and which depend on a house rule
- Apply the empty tray rules under the CLA and Pagat.com
- Choose the order in which to spend your safe cards
Practise with Canasta Meld Trainer: Is My Opening Legal?.
Lesson 5 introduced dead cards and the empty tray. Lesson 14 showed that your discard can be taken by one player only: the next player, on your left. This lesson puts those together. A discard is provably safe when the next player cannot take the pack with it, whatever cards they hold. You can check it from the table and your own count, with no guessing.
What provably safe means
There are three proofs. If any one of them holds, the next player cannot take the pack with your card:
- The rank is dead. Either team has finished a canasta of it.
- The next team has five or six cards of that rank on the table.
- At most one copy of the rank is unseen, so the next player cannot hold the natural pair a pick needs.
A card that passes none of the three may still be fine, and Lesson 17 is about judging those. But it is not proved safe.
Worked example. The pack has 8 cards. The next player's team has finished a canasta of nines and has J, J, J, J, J on the table. You hold a nine, a jack and a six.
- Nine: proof 1. Nines are dead.
- Jack: proof 2. Their five jacks plus a pair and the top card would be eight.
- Six: no proof. Nothing you can see rules out a pair of sixes in the next player's hand.
Question 1 of 5
Using the worked example, which of your three cards is not provably safe?