Lesson 17 of 1717 minMembers

Safe Discards II: Probably Safe

How to choose a discard when nothing is provably safe: what the next player's own discards tell you, what a card they let go by tells you, and how the size of the pack sets the cost of a mistake.

In this lesson

  • Read the next player's discards as evidence, and know where that evidence fails
  • Use a card the next player let go by
  • Weigh risk against the size of the pack
  • Rank every card in a hand from safest to most dangerous

Step 1 of 9

Steps 1 to 2 are free to try.

Most turns, no card in your hand is provably safe (Lesson 16). You still have to throw one. This lesson is about weighing the evidence you do have: what the next player has thrown, what they let go by, how many copies of a rank are still out, and how much is in the pack.

These are judgement calls, and good players weigh them differently. The questions in this lesson grade only what can be proved: what each piece of evidence shows and what it does not.

When nothing can be proved

Without a proof, you are ranking cards by how likely the next player is to hold a pair of them, and by how much it costs if they do. Some evidence points toward safety:

  • the next player threw that rank recently
  • the next player had a chance to take that rank and drew instead
  • few copies of the rank are unseen

Some points toward danger:

  • the next team has a meld of that rank, especially a meld of four, which a pick turns into a canasta
  • the pack is big, so a mistake hands over many cards

Worked example. The pack has 9 cards. The next team has K, K, K and 8, 8, 8, 8 on the table. Two turns ago the next player threw a jack. You hold J, 8, 4, 9, 9.

  • 8: the most dangerous card. Their four eights plus a pick make seven.
  • J: the best evidence. They threw a jack recently.
  • 4: nothing known either way.
  • 9, 9: a pair. Throwing one gives up a ticket (Lesson 15).

The jack is the natural choice here. It is still not proved safe.

Question 1 of 5

The next player threw a jack two turns ago. What does that prove about throwing a jack to them now?

Next: When nothing can be proved